Have you ever read a fanfic that was
popular and yet really bad? Did you make fun of it with your friends, complain
about it in chat, but not dare to say anything about it in public because
pissy authors and their friends will send you spam and flames instead of
admitting their work isn't perfect? Well, we're not putting up with that
anymore.
This is a fanfiction review site.
It's different from other sites because we're reviewing fic for the readers,
and not for the authors. We are not here to give authors compliments or
constructive criticism. We're tired of being flamed or accused of being
bitches when we try to tell someone their work has problems without giving
them five pages of compliments first. So screw the writers. This page is
for readers; think of it like a book or movie review page. We're just going
to say what we honestly think of fics. And you know what we think? Fanfic
writers are often attention-seeking crybabies who can't write, and they
need a slap to the fuckin' head.
If you have more questions, fic suggestions,
or if you want to insult/ flame/congratulate us, you can contact us here.
Or sign/read
our gbook.
WHO THE HELL ARE WE?
Just a group of fangirls who have
a duty. Our ranks grow in number daily! In order to help you figure out
why we might have given a fic the review we did, or to assist you in properly
flaming/debating with one of us, here are our pseudonyms and bios. (Note: we do not review our own writing; it's too hard to be objective. However, we may review each other's writing.)
REBEL TOY Hates bad grammar, angst, and bad love stories. Loves WAFF, humor, and smut.
#1 Fanfic Peeve: men/boys written to act like teenaged girls.
LEATHER DADDY I'm always finding the worst fics and purposely inflicting them on myself... and others.
#1 Fanfic Peeve: Fangirl Japanese.
MIDNIGHT MUTATION Hates seeing overdone cliches, characters that aren't in-character, and plot holes large enough to stuff the author's entire high school class in.
#1 Fanfic Peeve: Fic writers that ignore the established canon without a damn good reason to.
PINK FREAK Likes fun smut (and non-smut too) that keeps people in character. Hates many things including crying, JP in English fics, and the overemphasis of virginity.
#1 Fanfic Peeve: after much consideration, probably the usage of Japanese in a fic that is not a JP fic.
VICIOUS BABY Hates crybabies, the inability to use a spellchecker, Mary-Sue characters, and random, unexplained out-of-character behavior. Loves smut (PWP if it's handled right,) cheeze, original fics, satire fics, and comedies.
#1 Fanfic Peeve: Mary-Sue characters
FERAL CHEEKS Hates out-of-character being passed off as in-character, glaring cultural anachronisms, authors making comments inside their own stories.
#1 Fanfic Peeve: Overwrought descriptions (my, those melting chocolate eyes sound... tasty, I guess)
GILDED FANTASY Hates complete irreverance for canon and plausibility, out of canon relationships/ romance, angst. Likes well-written serious vingettes, parody and comedy.
#1 Fanfic Peeve: Gundam Wing Yaoi (subject to change)
PURPLE OUTCAST Hates out of character fics, self insertion/mary-sue fics, lack of character development and plot. Likes: When fic writers use logic.
#1 Fanfic Peeve: Those perfect mary-sue characters, my... they're so perfect why angst?
ELECTRIC DESIRE Hates mpreg, OOC, fanon, etc. Likes in-character fic, and proper use of grammar, spell-check, and hopefully at least one beta-reader.
#1 Fanfic Peeve: Fanon fic. Series/game? What series/game? That only impairs my fic...
VELVET VENUS Hates male characters turned into teenage girls, implausible relationships with no justification, OOC, stories that skimp on plot just to get to the smut. Likes parody, UST and smut. XD
#1 Fanfic Peeve: You are the uke, therefore your lose all character traits and turn into a crying little virgin.
INFO FOR MEMBERS
If it's not there, please add your name
and short bio to the side, and remember to use it.
Remember to put the series name and then the fic title; also remember to archive before writing a review. Archive format is SERIES :: FIC TITLE. (Name the html file whatever you want as long as it's pretty unique.) This will insure that the site is tidy and sexy.
Score: Wait a minute, I don't have to score this. Oh, what the heck.
PROCRASTINATION BECAUSE I DON'T WANT TO LOOK AT ANOTHER EVIL FIC FOR A LITTLE WHILE: 5/5
As you've been reading these reviews, you may have seen us fling about terms and phrases that you may not have been familiar with.
We assume that readers of this page have a background in generic fan-terms, but that's a pretty hefty assumption. So, instead of taking notes on how many times 'cuntal'
is used as an adjective in a fic (I'll leave that to Rebel Toy...I found a fic so bad that even I couldn't review it without laughing until my sides hurt), I'll attempt to decipher some of the Fic Bitch vocabulary.
Lemon: This refers to a piece of fanfiction with explicit sexual
content. I understand that the source of this term comes from an early pornographic anime called "Cream Lemon." If you want
to think about it in another way, if you squeeze a lemon, it juices all over your hand. Call it 'filthy smut' if you prefer that.
Hentai/H/Ecchi: means it's filthy smut. 'Hentai' means 'perverted'. 'Ecchi' is just how you would say 'H' - the first letter of Hentai - out loud.
Mary Sue: Now, this term might have REALLY confused you if you don't read a lot of fanfiction. A Mary Sue is an author avatar - a self-insert, put more simply. Just about everyone has wished that they could 'jump into' the world of their favorite
show/series/book and meet the characters (or the real people, if we're talking musical groups). Most of us, however, never inflict these desires on the general public. Those who do - write Mary Sues. I was going to say that you outgrow the urge to write yourself
into a story, but that would be a complete lie. The most famous Mary Sue (or Marty Stu for male ones, I suppose) would be Wesley Crusher from Star Trek, the series created by Eugene Wesley Rodenberry. :P (For that reason, male Mary Sues may also be called "Wesleys".)
But as I was saying before I got completely sidetracked, was that the main problem with Mary Sues is that they are so incredibly annoying to read about. These Mary Sues are almost invariably perfect, multi-talented, and a boy/girl magnet. Everyone (especially the author's favorite character) falls in love with them, or is their father, or something like that.
They appear out of nowhere, are embraced into the canon, and are given important positions in the hierarchy (in Fushigi Yuugi, it would be something like a new Miko, or in, um, an Anne Rice book, it would be an incredibly talented, previously-unknown member of those wankers, the Talamasca.) If they're not important in
the entire universe of the book/series, then they're given a major role in the lives of the characters, usually supplanting the heroine/hero or their boyfriend/girlfriend. Again, going with the Anne Rice example here, this mysterious, highly-talented member of the Talamasca would meet, um, Louis (who we all know is about as straight as a doughnut) and makes him fall PASSIONATELY in love with her, wiping his little hangups with Claudia and Lestat clean out of his mind, and then he, uh, makes her a vampire or something, so that they can be together forever.
Gosh, I'm a bit scared at how easy it is for me to speculate on the plot of these things, and then to realize that someone's probably already written it.
Are you beginning to get the idea? USUALLY the Mary Sue is an incredibly annoying original character. However, sometimes the Mary Sue infects a canonical character, transforming the character into a clone of the author. For example, I recently read a Harry Potter fic in which Ron Weasley, who I always thought was your standard Guy(tm) in the making, grew up to be a long-haired, anorexic waif who sobbed about his tragic unrequited love for Harry Potter. I couldn't
even begin to explain how weird it was to read this fic. The emotionally scarred, physically frail Ron, who hadn't eaten for a week, who could count his ribs in the mirror, and who fainted from malnutrition or something at the end of the first chapter, had absolutely no resemblance to the Ron Weasley I remembered from the books. It became crystal clear that either the author was smoking some pretty powerful shit, or that they had somehow wriggled into Ron's skin and turned him into, well, themselves. It's kind of both frustrating and creepy to read about those Mary Sues...you
feel like you're getting a slightly voyeuristic peek into the personal problems and issues of a complete stranger. Ick.
"Wait!" Authors might say. "My original character isn't a Mary Sue! Look, s/he has FLAWS!" Yes, but are they noble, tragic flaws, such as the flaws you'd make up at a job interview when asked what your weaknesses were? "I'm too self-sacrificing. I beat myself up over things that aren't my fault, but because I'm so noble, I angst about them anyways. I'm a perfectionist; I have to make everything run smoothly." A Tragic Past is the hallmark of a Mary Sue, as is pointless angsting or a Noble Death, where all the canon characters sob about how noble Mary Sue's sacrifice was.
Another good page explaining the Mary Sue phenomenon has pointed out a quick test for a Mary Sue: if you take genuine criticism - not flaming, but criticism - of said original character very personally, there's a high risk that it's a Mary Sue. (Because, of course, criticism of the Mary Sue feels like peronal criticism, since you probably share so many traits.)
This entire explanation was cribbed from several good sites - I don't claim to be the most original analyst of the Mary Sue phenomenon. But I'd be hard-pressed to say anything that these sites haven't said, and said better than I did.
PWP: stands for "Plot? What Plot?" Basically, there are two kinds of smutty fics: ones that pretend to be high-brow, and those which admit that they're essentially padded sex scenes. The latter are called "PWP", and the former are called all kinds of silly euphemisms such as 'sekkishiaru roman' (sexual stories) or the like. I'm not saying that the presence of sex in a fic makes it a smutty, plotless lemon. I'm just saying that if the point of the story is to talk about two characters getting it on, Romaaaaaantically or otherwise, the plot IS the smut, so you might as well call it a PWP. And no, I'm not saying that smut
is bad either. Look at what the hell I've been reviewing!
WAFF : stands for Warm and Fuzzy Feeling. Self-explanatory, right? Either this is a feeble excuse for writing characters so saccharinely romantic that it makes me cringe, or for writing a fic that involves people treating each other nicely without bastardizing their characterization, in which case I go "Awww" and want to hug the monitor. I'm a cranky, cynical bitch, but well-done WAFFy fic is a joy to read, and makes you smile after finishing it.
OOC: Out-Of-Character. Avoid this unless you can really do this well and justify it, which you probably can't.
Yaoi: Essentially 'slash', but usually applied to male homosexual relationships between characters in Japanese games, manga, novels, anime, whatnot. You WILL, however, see things such as 'X-Files yaoi' which sounds WEIRD to me. 'Yaoi' is an acronym for something that I don't remember off the top of my head ( " yama nashi, ochi nashi, imi nashi" - No Climax, No Resolution, No Meaning? something like that) but my favorite acronym for YAOI is "YAmete! Oshiti ga Itai!" ("Stop it! My butt hurts!")
Yuri: involves lesbian relationships. I understand this came from early Dirty Pair fanfiction involving Kei and Yuri. I might be wrong.
Fanon: 'Canon' is 'the works of a writer that have been generally accepted as being authentic.' FANON, on the other hand, is a particular storyline, characterization, whatever you like, that sprung up in the fan community. Some fanon characters deviate wildly from their canon characterization, become extremely popular among fanficcers, and some of them may eventually forget that the fanon characterization is NOT THE ORIGINAL ONE. An example that springs to mind is that of Draco Malfoy, from the Harry Potter books. In the books, he's a selfish, petty, spoilt brat. However, in the fan community, he's become some kind of bizarre divine anti-hero, sarcastic, witty, angelically beautiful, and prone to wander about in form-fitting black clothes. His character flaws have been varnished and buffed into a glossy shine, until all you can see is a typical 'bad boy'. Bleh. All well and good, but don't forget that THAT'S NOT HOW HE'S WRITTEN.
Seme: the 'top' in a gay relationship. The one doing the spelunking. The one finding the South Pole. The one whose Tab A inserts into the uke's Slot B.
Uke: the 'bottom'. In a lot of stories, this means that he's made into a snivelling, crying little girl who feels 'fulfilled' by the seme. Filled, maybe.
That's all I can think of at this second. And no, I'm not going to alphabetize this; we're all big boys and girls around here.
I wonder if this was such a good review/lexicon entry to write at work....
This slap to the head was administered at 02:38 p.m. on Wednesday, December 19, 2001.